-
West Midlands Shoppers Urged to Guard Against Black Friday Scams
-
GIRLBAND! Headline Show at Rough Trade Marks National Breakthrough
-
Surfshark Adds Real-Time Call Protection to iOS App in Version 5.3.0
-
Samsung Galaxy Buds Active Leak Reveals ANC, Ear-Hook Design and One UI 9.5 Integration
-
Saudi PIF Retains Top Sovereign Wealth Fund Brand Title for Third Year
-
Egypt and Syria Sign Agreement to Restore Direct Flights After 14-Year Hiatus
-
Professor Shahida Moosa Pioneers Medical Genomics in South Africa Amid Testing Shortages
-
Van Gogh’s ‘Châtaigniers en Fleurs’ Sets $285m Record at Sotheby’s
-
Texas Marijuana Decriminalization Faces Uncertain Future Under New Attorney General
-
Anthropic Sets Record $81.3 Billion IPO Valuing AI Firm at $1.5 Trillion
-
Early Black Friday Laptop Deals: MacBook Neo, IdeaPad Slim 5x, and Surface Laptop Prices Drop
-
eThekwini Faces R6.5bn Flood Claim from Toyota’s Insurer
-
2026 East Bay Nosh Awards Voting Opens for Food and Drink Favorites
-
More Than Half of Teen AI Chatbot Users Use Them Daily, and 46% Say It Feels Like Talking to a Human, New Family Online Safety Institute Research Finds
-
After 20 Years of Modernizing Other Companies' Software, Polcode Turns the Lens on Itself
-
MicroVision and Blue-Band to Support $3 Million Federally Funded Intelligent Transportation Initiative in Louisville, Kentucky
-
The 2026 MDaudit Annual Benchmark Report Spotlights AI's Impact on Financial Risk as Payer Denials and Audits Continue an Upward Trajectory
-
Metano Emerges From Stealth to Unify AI Agent Security Across the Enterprise
-
Lumber's Union CBA Agent Launches in Sage Agent Marketplace to Help Simplify Union Payroll Compliance
-
ATWEC Technologies, Inc. (OTCID: ATWT) Engages Michael Gillespie & Associates, PLLC to Audit Fiscal 2026 and 2025 Consolidated Financial Statements and Changes Fiscal Year End to October 31
-
Vogenx Set to Join the Russell 2000(R), Russell 3000(R), and Russell Microcap(R) Indexes
-
Stemtech Corporation Partners with Fitness Icon Tony Little to Launch Stemtech Biosciences Digital Campaign
-
Go Green Global Technologies Corp. Appoints Dennis Beckert as Interim Chief Executive Officer
-
InstaLILY Launches Lily for Sales on Microsoft Dynamics 365, Where Sellers and AI Agents Work Together in Shared Rooms
-
Wave AI, the AI Note Taker for In-Person Meetings, Passes 5 Million Recorded Hours
-
Increasing Electrification Raises Grid Risk and Cost Pressure for Industrial Sites, ABI Research Finds
-
Jerash Holdings Partners with International Finance Corporation (IFC) to Pursue EDGE Gender Certification
-
Lexaria's Human Study GLP-1-H26-7 Completes Dosing as Scheduled
-
Philadelphia Sexual Assault Lawyer David P. Thiruselvam Explains Who Can Be Named in a Civil Sexual Assault Claim
-
Long Island Capital Alliance to Host Technology Capital Forum
-
BlackBerry and Hazard Management Cayman Islands Renew Critical Alerting System for Emergencies and Public Safety
-
Celtic Bank Selects Infinant to Scale Its Embedded Finance Programs
-
Making the Most of a Long Weekend Without Leaving Town
-
Gamma Resources Announces Expansion of Mesa Arc Uranium Project in New Mexico to 4,760 Acres, Completes Radon Flux Baseline Survey
-
Bob's Watches Founder Paul Altieri Unveils Private Collection of Vintage Rolex Watches in New Book, "NOT FOR SALE"
-
InterContinental Hotels Group PLC Announces Transaction in Own Shares - November 19
-
Hemogenyx Pharmaceuticals PLC - Chairman Receives Prestigious Award
-
American Critical Minerals Reports High Grade Potash Intersection of 6.55m Grading 38.51 wt.% KCl at its Green River Project, Utah
-
LASE to Premiere Quantum Bullet(TM) at Counter UAS Technology Conference in Washington, D.C.
-
First Canadian Graphite Reports 43.9% Graphitic Carbon Sample and Encouraging Coarse-Flake Characteristics at Zone 13 at Lac Guéret South
-
IRS Shuts Down FIRE Today: What Information Return Filers Need to Know Before the 2027 Filing Season
-
NoHo, Inc. Acquires Four Placer Gold Claims in Clark County, Nevada from Gold Stake Mining Inc.
-
Trustpoint Xposure Completes More Than 200 AI Visibility Audits Across Professional Services
-
QNX Brings Physical AI and Next-Generation Software-Defined Vehicle Innovation to CES 2027
-
Golden Minerals Completes Drilling Desierto, Argentina
-
Guanajuato Silver Reports Q3 Operating and Financial Results
-
Helio Corporation Engages CORE IR to Provide Investor Relations, Capital Markets Advisory and Media Relations Services
-
Greene Concepts Connects Consumer Needs with Manufacturing Strategy
-
Karbon-X (OTCQB:KARX) Enters California's Multi-Billion-Dollar Compliance Carbon Market Following CITSS Approval
-
Skilled Nursing Facilities Face 2027 Revenue Cycle Reckoning as Payer Burdens Reshape Admissions and Outsourcing
Seizing Russian assets is easier said than done
The idea is seductively simple: the West should turn over billions of dollars of frozen Russian assets to Ukraine to fund reconstruction. But it faces major legal problems which mean little progress has been made.
After the Kremlin's invasion of Ukraine last February, unprecedented economic sanctions against Moscow saw an estimated $350 billion in state assets, foreign reserves and oligarch property frozen by Western banks and officials.
Nearly 12 months on, politicians and campaigners in the West are pushing for this idle wealth to be put to work rebuilding the shattered infrastructure, homes and businesses destroyed during Russia's aggression.
"So much damage has been done and the country that did the damage should pay," Canadian Deputy Prime Minister and Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland told an audience at the World Economic Forum last month.
In December, Canada began proceedings for the first time to turn over around $26 million belonging to a sanctioned company owned by oligarch Roman Abramovich -- something Russia's ambassador likened to "robbery in broad daylight".
Earlier this month, the European Commission pledged to "step up its work towards the use of Russia's frozen assets to support Ukraine's reconstruction". Poland and three Baltic states pressed publicly for action "as soon as possible".
Estonia has announced plans to be a frontrunner in the EU, drawing up its own confiscation plans.
"Putin broke it, he should fix it," former US investor and activist Bill Browder, a dogged campaigner against the Kremlin, told AFP in a recent interview.
The man behind the Magnitsky Act -- pioneering legislation to sanction Russian government officials involved in human rights abuses -- is now seeking to build pressure on lawmakers.
"There are 50 different alternative proposals for how to do it. And if you want to make sure that something never gets done, present 50 different proposals," Browder said.
The US Congress has been holding hearings on ways in which US law could be changed to enable permanent seizures, although President Joe Biden's administration has been publicly cautious about the idea.
- Proceeds of crime? -
Legal experts make a distinction between private assets frozen by Western governments -- such as an oligarch's yacht -- and state property, such as the foreign currency reserves of Russia's central bank.
In the case of private assets, legal safeguards mean Western states are permitted to permanently seize them only in very limited circumstances -- usually when they can be proven to be the proceeds of crime.
And even though Russian oligarchs operate in the murky weeds of Russian capitalism "we don't really know that the properties that have been frozen are the proceeds of crime," Anton Moiseienko from the Australian National University told AFP.
Seizing them poses a challenge to fundamental legal and human rights, such as the right to property, protection from arbitrary punishment, or the right to a free trial.
The West's public commitment to respecting the rule of law would also be on the line.
"How are you going to prove that they (the seized assets) constitute the proceeds of crime without the cooperation of Russia?" Moiseienko, an international law expert, added.
Other problems arise due to bilateral or international investment treaties signed with Russia, potentially exposing states to legal claims in international arbitration courts further down the line.
Canada so far is the only state so far to take what Moiseienko calls a "uniquely aggressive approach".
"It will be interesting to see how it plays out in court," he added.
- Immunity -
State assets such as central bank reserves pose different but equally knotty problems because they are covered by so-called "sovereign immunity" -- an understanding that one state will not seize another's property.
Western central banks such as the Federal Reserve, the European Central Bank or the Bank of Japan are thought to have blocked reserves worth around $300 billion held with them by Russia.
"The customary international law of state immunity generally protects state assets from seizure," Paul B. Stephen wrote in the Capital Markets Law Journal last June in a review of existing legislation.
"Exceptions exist, but their scope is unclear," he added.
A lively debate has taken place between scholars since Russia's invasion about the circumstances under which Western states could "vest" assets such as central bank reserves.
Some have invoked the international law of countermeasures, which holds that one state can impose costs on another when it is acting outside the bounds of international law.
But so-called "countermeasures" are meant to be reversible.
Many lawyers believe Ukraine's best chance of compensation is to try to force a favourable agreement to end the fighting, which would include reparations -- which it is entitled to under international law.
But others argue for a more radical approach which would send a message to other states, including China.
"It seems illogical that Putin can invent new types of crimes and we cannot reinvent a legal framework to respond to those crimes," Browder told AFP.
D.Moore--AMWN